The missed (double) penalty for Inter in the match against Atalanta continues to spark debate, but this morning’s Corriere dello Sport offers a reconstruction of a rather bizarre affair. Referee Gianluca Manganiello reportedly received a rating well above passing, despite the serious error on the Scalvini–Frattesi contact and the subsequent Ederson–Dumfries incident. VAR Gariglio and AVAR Chiffi will soon be back on the field, with the latter also serving as VAR in the Lazio vs Milan match on the same day.
The rating assigned by Gervasoni, head of VAR and deputy to Rocchi, is said to be around 8.50, which in refereeing rankings would be equivalent to a 7 in school grades. A rating that the newspaper describes as “even more inexplicable than the missed penalty itself.” The most contested episode concerns the foul by Scalvini on Frattesi, eerily reminiscent of the penalty awarded to Verona after an On Field Review during the match against Inter in January 2024. An objective error that would have deserved a sanction. In the same play, the contact between Ederson and Dumfries also sparked debate: there were mutual holds between the two, but the Atalanta midfielder then extended his right leg in a foul manner, causing the Inter winger to fall.
The last controversial episode of the match concerns the contact between Sulemana and Dumfries which led to the visitors’ 1-1 goal, where according to Corriere dello Sport there should have been “a whistle that 99% of referees would have given.”